South Asian Insider
Jammu and Kashmir: Detention is not the answer
Booking the former chief ministers under PSA is counterproductive
The decision to book former Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) chief ministers Omar Abdullah and Mehbooba Mufti under the Public Safety Act (PSA), which allows for detention up to two years, is ethically questionable, legally flawed, and politically counterproductive. The two leaders were booked under PSA soon after completing six months in preventive detention. Omar's father, former CM Farooq Abdullah, is also detained under PSA. Sections of the media have cited a government dossier outlining the charges. If these reports are accurate, Omar Abdullah has been accused of espousing radical ideology, of having the capacity to influence people and encouraging an agitation, and of instigating people against India. Ms Mufti, too, has been reportedly, accused of promoting separatism, and making provocative statements which have led to violence.
The government's approach over the detention of leaders is disconcerting. For one, it violates the spirit of the Constitution. Individual liberty is at the heart of the democratic constitution. The government has shown no tangible evidence which suggests that the Abdullahs or Ms Mufti had done anything to stir violence or seek to break up the Union. Yes, these leaders have been critical of the government's decision to effectively nullify Article 370 in the state and divide it. Yes, they run parties which can organise demonstrations in opposition to these moves. But this is their fundamental right as Indian citizens. If the government truly wants to integrate J&K with the Union, it cannot do so without giving to the citizens in J&K the same rights exercised by Indians elsewhere. It also cannot do so unless democratic activity gets restored, which can truly happen only when these leaders get released.
The move also undermines the Indian State's interests. The Abdullahs and Ms Mufti, in the most difficult of times, when the street mood was laced with resentment against Delhi, and when terror groups from Pakistan wreaked havoc, have stood up for the Union. The current charges against them defy common sense - for it is almost an implicit suggestion that their backing of the Constitution and democracy merits punishment. Will this not strengthen those who are against India? The Centre may want to encourage a new force in Kashmir's polity - but it must not happen by curtailing individual rights. Delhi is weakening its own political and diplomatic case on Kashmir.
Coronavirus update: H-1B workers seek 180 instead of 60-day stay in US amid layoffs
Foreign IT professionals, a majority of them Indians with H-1B visas in the US, have urged the Trump administration to extend their permissible stay f...
Pompeo dials Jaishankar, says ‘our close cooperation is imperative to combat coronavirus’
In a telephonic conversation, US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo spoke with External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar regarding the coordination of effort...
Brooklyn man arrested for hoarding masks, coughing on FBI agents
A Brooklyn man claiming to be infected with the coronavirus coughed on FBI agents who were investigating him for hoarding medical supplies, the US Att...
Will the coronavirus kill the oil industry and help save the climate?
The plunging demand for oil wrought by the coronavirus pandemic combined with a savage price war has left the fossil fuel industry broken and in survi...
How to sustain a long lockdown
By now, we have all seen the heart-wrenching images of migrants in Delhi scrambling to board buses out of the city. If even a small number of them wer...
Fake WhatsApp messages spurred migrants’ exodus from Delhi to UP, say officials
Fake messages widely circulated on social media could have played a key role in spurring the exodus of migrants from Delhi to Uttar Pradesh, said stat...
One-third of migrant workers could be infected with Covid-19: Centre tells SC
The government told the Supreme Court on Tuesday that there is a possibility that three out of 10 people moving from cities to rural areas are carryin...
India coronavirus cases rise amid fears true figure much higher
Low levels of testing and poor access to healthcare means many people not reporting Doubt has been cast over India’s claim that it has no community...
Coronavirus update: India bans exports of Trump-backed virus drug as global demand surges
US?President Donald Trump has vowed to make the medication widely available to fight the pandemic, calling the drug a “game changer” in the treatment ...
China claims it beat coronavirus but does anyone believe it? 'The truth has always been a casualty
As China and the United States race to restart their economies amid a global pandemic, foreign affairs experts say Beijing's claim of a slowdown of CO...
© All rights Reserved. The south Asian, Published Weekly from New york.